The following are some of the practical aspects of choosing and using Neutral Density (ND) filters.
What are ND filters?
- Dark glass (or resin) which allow a photographer to lengthen the shutter speed.
- Screw on (circular) vs Square (slot in) – see below in accessories
- Light blocking terminology:
|Stops blocked||1 stop||2 stop||3 stop||10 stop|
|No filter = 1 sec||2sec||4sec||8sec||1024sec|
- Tripod: must be firm and steady
- Cable release : essential to achieve exposures of greater than 30 seconds. Some firmware changes such as ‘magic lantern’ and some camera applications (such as for the sony A7r series) offer an alternative to a cable release but I prefer the former.
- Filter holder and square filter set up. Allows 2(Lee default) to 3(Nisi default) filters to be stacked in front of the camera. Lee requires an additional slot for a 105mm CPL, Nisi system has a CPL attached to the default sized adaptor ring itself. Insert ND filter on the closest filter slot with padding firm against edges of the holder to prevent light leak.
- Screw on filters need no filter kit. These minimise light leak but are unable to ‘stack’ with other filters. Can be used with CPL but could lead to vignetting.
- Optical view finder cover (to prevent more light leak). Can be on the camera strap itself (Canon) or can be anything invented ! eg. Blue-tac, duct tape.
Density recommendations (approximate)
- 2-3 stop : for waterfalls, seascapes in bright light : target shutter 0.5-5 seconds
- 6 stop : for fast moving clouds, seascapes in low light: target shutter 5-60-seconds
- 10 stop: for elimination of water textures, slowish clouds: target shutter 1-5 minutes
- 15 stop: same target as 10 stop except in brighter conditions: target shutter 1-20 minutes
- Vari-ND: limited by screw on setup and some brands have bad cross polarisation artefact.
Camera setup :
- Turn off long exposure noise reduction. (noise reduce in post processing)
- Turn off autofocus . Leaving it on may result in the camera hunting in the dark for and lead to an out of focus image
- Keep ISO low. This is within camera limitations. I like to keep ISO <400. (if going much higher, could you just achieve the same results with camera settings alone or less dense ND filter?)
- Activate expanded ISO (eg. ISO50 for Canon users)
- Adjust aperture according to given scene. At your lens’s sweet spot at f8, the exposure may not be long enough after minimising ISO and placing your most dense ND filter.
- Usual rules of composition apply
- ND filters allow simplification of ‘chaotic’ elements eg random water motion, unattractive clouds. Use these to emphasise areas of detail within your image
- Compose without ND filter on to achieve your desired composition and to find your focal point manually.
- Don’t let the ND filter dictate the shutter speed. Use ND filters to achieve the shutter speed you desire for the scene.
- For every stop of light blocked, exposure duration doubles. (See first table)
- Use apps if you don’t mind bringing devices into the field
- Alternatively, use this approach
How long do I want?
- See the above section in ‘density recommendations’
- Start with that filter and adjust ISO/aperture accordingly to achieve the exact shutter that you need for the scene.
- During your test exposures without the ND filters, take some dedicated shots with shorter shutter. You might like them more!
With or without filters?
- Think about combining filters to achieve a single exposure result
- Using an additional GND for the sky
- Avoid stacking ND filters as the filter in the 2nd slot will almost certainly let light leak in
- Think about taking an image for dark areas of the scene without the ND filter on as the ND filter will require a very long exposure for deeply shadowed areas. Blend them in post processing.
Ultimately, repetition leads to reflexes and if the routine is a reflex, more thought can go into the art of achieving a result instead of the mathematical and technical processes of using filters. Enjoy!
Disclosure: I am a Nisi brand ambassador who tries to write neutrally and objectively. If you are interested in purchasing filters after reading this article, feel free to email us dm@everlookphotography and I will be able to give a discount code for Australian customers.
19 thoughts on “Neutral Density Filters”
you don’t know how much your pictures inspired me. I have 3 stop and 6 stop breakthrough brand Circular filters.I am confused to add Circular Polarizer Filter or Lee ND grad medium 3 stop.
Hey Womny – thanks very much for following our work. If you have circular ND filters, unfortunately your options for using a CPL and grads are quite limited. Adding a CPL will probably lead to vignetting. If you want to shoot with a style that incorporates ND filters, CPLs and GND filters together, I would look at investing a rectangular filter system with a slotted filter holder. This would allow you various ways to combine the above. Also, a CPL and GND 3 stop have completely different functions – have a look at our post on using a circular polariser for more information on this!
I’m thinking about adding ND Grads to my filter collection – for general landscape photography would you recommend getting a full set of Soft, Medium or Hard Edge Grads first? I would get the 1,2 and 3 stop ND Grads as a set (to get the discount!) – Cheers 🙂
b.t.w. I’m on Mirrorless if that makes any difference…thanks again.
Hi Brian – sorry I didn’t reply sooner on this thread – if I were choosing I would go straight for a 3 stop medium GND.
I don’tn feel that you get much use or benefit out of a 1-2 stop soft .
Your tutorial was absolutely awesome! I just purchased the NiSi Beginners kit (comes with GND 3 stop and ND 10 stop). Would buying the ND 6 be enough to have a fairly rounded off system for a fairly novice photographer?
For sure! In fact, I reckon I use the 6 stop more often than the 10 🙂 Particularly as light is fading
Thanks! Decision made!
What about variable ND filter? Does it work as good as the stacked filters?
I’ve had limited experience with only two Vari NDs – in both I found that at the upper end of the recommended strengths, there were some cross polarisation problems. It also is a screw on and has the limitations associated with those. I would not advise stacking dense ND filters due to the possibility of light leak for the filter in the 2nd slot (unless you can seal it up with a home made solution)
Reblogged this on Shoot It Now.
How good are these shots! WOW. Love the dead trees on the lake. Great info as always.
Thanks Andrew! I love a good long exposure to match the short exposure shot of the scene 🙂 Lake Bonney’s a beauty!
How to calculate how many stop it has?
At this moment I use ND8 and ND32 how many stop it has
Nd8 is 3 stops, ND32 is 5 stops (exponential values of 2)
no worries 🙂
as a starting point, which nd and gnd should i buy ? thx
if you want to go safe, the 3 stop soft GND is easiest to use, and probably a 6 stop ND. It does however depend on what you plan to shoot